
When administrative work piles up, most business owners weigh two paths: hire a full-time employee, or bring in a virtual assistant. The comparison usually starts and ends with the hourly rate or the salary, and that is exactly where the comparison goes wrong. If you are still deciding what kind of support you need, our guide to executive assistant versus administrative support helps with that first question. The real question is what it truly costs to get the work done reliably, and on that question the numbers look very different from either headline figure.
Here is a side-by-side breakdown of the full cost of each option, and how to decide which fits your situation.
If you would like to talk through which path fits your business, you can book a free 30-minute discovery call with Tammy. You can also reach us at tammy@lairdvs.com or 865-306-9099.
The full cost of a full-time employee
A salary is only the beginning. When a US small business hires a full-time administrative employee, the true annual cost includes:
- Salary. A full-time administrative hire represents a substantial salary commitment every year, paid regardless of how the workload fluctuates week to week. For exact figures, current salary data for your area and role is the right reference; the direction is enough for this comparison: it is by far the largest line item.
- Payroll taxes and required contributions. Social Security, Medicare, unemployment insurance, and workers’ compensation add a meaningful percentage on top of every salary dollar.
- Benefits. Health insurance, retirement contributions, and other benefits are often expected for full-time roles and can add thousands more per employee per year.
- Paid time off. Vacation, sick days, and holidays are paid while the work still needs covering, either by you or by a temp.
- Workspace and equipment. A desk, computer, software licenses, and in many cases office space itself, whether leased square footage or a corner of your home that stops being yours.
- Recruiting and onboarding. Posting the role, interviewing, background checks, and weeks of training before full productivity, plus the cost of doing it again if the hire does not work out.
- Management time. Someone supervises, reviews, and develops the employee. In a small business, that someone is usually the owner.
- Turnover risk. When an employee leaves, the recruiting, onboarding, and ramp-up costs restart, and coverage gaps appear in the meantime.
Add those layers together and the salary is best understood as roughly the starting point of the real annual commitment, not the total.
The full cost of a virtual assistant
The virtual assistant model prices differently because the structure is different:
- Pay for productive work. You pay for hours worked or a defined scope, not for 40 paid hours regardless of demand. A slow week costs less than a busy one.
- No benefits or payroll burden. VAs are contracted, not employed by you, so the payroll taxes, benefits, and PTO layers do not apply.
- No workspace or equipment cost. A remote professional works from their own office with their own equipment.
- Minimal onboarding. The investment is a written process and a short ramp-up, not a multi-week training program.
- Flexibility to scale. Hours can grow or shrink with your workload. Seasonal swings stop being a staffing problem.
- Coverage, depending on the model. Working through an agency usually includes backup if your assistant is unavailable; hiring a freelancer directly means coverage is your responsibility, which is one of the honest tradeoffs between the two.
The hourly rate for a qualified virtual assistant is often higher than an employee’s raw hourly-equivalent salary figure. That is not a trick; it reflects paying only for productive, supported, vetted work rather than the full employment structure around it.
The math owners usually miss
Two comparisons matter more than the rate:
Utilization. An employee is paid for every scheduled hour, but no one’s workload fills every hour at peak efficiency. If a full-time hire is meaningfully busy for, say, half of their paid hours, you are paying full salary for half the output. A VA engaged for the actual volume of work costs closer to what the work really needs.
Your time. Employment adds management, and in a small business management comes from you: reviewing, directing, and supervising. With a flexible VA arrangement, especially through a service that handles vetting and accountability, much of that burden is carried for you. Time you do not spend managing is time for the work only you can do.
This is why the honest framing of the comparison is the total cost of getting the work done reliably, a theme we also cover in our guide to virtual assistant pricing and what to consider before you hire. And the hours themselves are worth pricing too: here is what a virtual assistant can accomplish in just one hour.
When a full-time hire still makes sense
A fair comparison says the employee path wins in real situations:
- The work is full-time and steady. If there is genuinely 40 hours a week of varied, in-person-dependent work for the foreseeable future, an employee’s cost spread across that volume can be efficient.
- Presence matters. Front-desk roles, hands-on tasks, or work that requires being physically in the building cannot be done remotely.
- Deep institutional knowledge is the goal. A long-tenured employee accumulates context and relationships that a flexible arrangement may not match.
- You want to build a management layer. For businesses growing toward a larger team, an in-house hire with growth potential can be part of that plan.
The point is not that one option is always right. It is that each is right for a different shape of workload.
A practical way to decide
Before choosing, get specific about your situation:
- Tally the real workload. How many hours a week does the work actually need? Track it for two weeks rather than estimating.
- Price the employee option fully. Salary plus taxes, benefits, space, equipment, and your management time.
- Price the VA option at that workload. Hours or scope, at the rates quoted to you.
- Weigh flexibility and risk. How stable is the workload? What happens if it drops or doubles? What is the cost of a bad hire versus ending a contract arrangement?
For many small businesses, the workload that prompted the decision is 10 to 25 hours a week of administrative support, and at that volume the VA path is usually the clearer value. For a genuinely full-time, steady, in-person role, the employment path can justify itself. If you are not sure which tasks would come off your plate first, 10 Tasks You Should Hand Off to a Virtual Assistant Today is the place to start, and how a virtual assistant gives you back 5–10 hours every week shows the arithmetic from the owner’s side.
If you want help sizing your workload and comparing the two paths with real numbers, schedule a free 30-minute discovery call with Tammy, or email tammy@lairdvs.com or call 865-306-9099.
The bottom line
A full-time employee brings a full employment structure: salary plus taxes, benefits, space, equipment, management, and turnover risk, paid against every scheduled hour. A virtual assistant brings productive hours on demand, without the structure, at a rate that reflects vetted, supported work. Neither is automatically cheaper or better; the answer comes from matching the arrangement to the actual shape of your workload. Once you have chosen, how to hire a virtual assistant for your small business covers the next step.
Ready to run your own comparison with real numbers? Book a free 30-minute discovery call with Tammy and tell us what the workload looks like.
You can also email tammy@lairdvs.com, call 865-306-9099, or visit www.lairdvirtualsolutions.com.
Laird Virtual Solutions supports business owners across the United States.
A note from Tammy:
I welcome everyone to have a chat with me. If you are feeling stuck or overwhelmed, or you need help with anything at all, please reach out. We will talk through what is going on and work out what would genuinely help.


